Can You Change How People See Your Industry?

We’re trying to change what customers think about loan brokers. It hasn’t been easy.

I recently returned from the National Association of Government Guaranteed Lenders conference, where hundreds of SBA lenders, bankers, and industry professionals gathered to discuss the state of small-business lending. I always enjoy these conferences, but this year I came home thinking about something that has very little to do with interest rates, credit policies, or the SBA itself.

I’ve been building MultiFunding for more than 15 years. We’re a loan brokerage firm, which means we help business owners find financing and work with lenders to close their transactions. But I’ve learned that the moment I tell someone in the banking industry I’m a broker, they often make assumptions about what we do. They think brokers are where borrowers go when they’re desperate because they can’t get a loan anywhere else. They assume we spend our days dealing with difficult credits, troubled businesses, and transactions already rejected by multiple banks. And to be fair, some brokers operate exactly that way. The perception didn’t come out of nowhere.

But the business we’ve been building is based on a very different premise. We believe that many perfectly good borrowers waste enormous amounts of time and energy because they start their financing process with the wrong lender. 

Here’s an example: Two banks can look at the same loan application and reach completely different conclusions. One might love a particular industry while another avoids it. One might be comfortable financing an acquisition with limited collateral, while another wants hard assets. One might welcome working with a startup, while another won’t consider a business without several years of operating history. Neither bank is necessarily wrong. They just have different appetites for risk.

The problem is that most entrepreneurs don’t know these differences exist. They assume that all banks that offer SBA loans will come to the same conclusion when evaluating a loan. So they approach the bank where they have their checking account, or perhaps a banker someone recommended, and begin the process.

Weeks or months later, they may get turned down. At that point, they’ve invested considerable time, their confidence has been shaken, and sometimes an important transaction is in jeopardy. They may conclude that their business isn’t financeable or that the SBA lending process is broken. In reality, another lender might have been enthusiastic about the same transaction from the beginning.

This is the problem we’re trying to solve. Last year, we funded loans with 27 different lenders, with each lender selected intentionally based on our understanding of its credit preferences and appetite for risk. The idea is to make lender selection a strategic decision at the start of the process, not a desperate search after something goes wrong.

But here’s where the broader business lesson comes in. We’re not just trying to convince customers that we’re better at something. We’re trying to convince them to think about the problem differently in the first place. And that’s a much harder marketing challenge. If someone believes that a loan broker is only useful after a bank has rejected them, it doesn’t matter how good our process is or how many lenders we work with. It won’t occur to that person to call us until something has gone wrong.

I’ve been thinking about how this applies to other entrepreneurs. Most businesses compete within established categories. Restaurant owners can be pretty confident that potential customers understand what a restaurant does. Accounting firms know most people have a pretty good idea of when they need an accountant. Their marketing challenge is to explain why customers should choose them instead of a competitor.

But what happens when your strategy depends on changing when people think they need you, or even whether they need you at all? You have to do more than explain your services. You have to educate the market about a problem customers may not realize they have. And that takes patience.

One thing we’re learning is that our biggest competitors aren’t necessarily other brokerage firms. It’s the deeply ingrained habit of business owners going directly to the bank they already know, where they may think they have a personal connection. It’s even the assumption among some lenders that brokers only bring them deals that other banks don’t want. Both perceptions are understandable. Both are reinforced by years of experience. And neither is going to disappear because we come up with a clever marketing campaign.

We’ve also discovered that this thinking affects recruiting, too. When we talk to experienced bankers about joining our team, some have a hard time getting past the idea of becoming a broker. They’ve spent their careers on the lending side of the table, and in their minds, moving into brokerage can feel like a step backward.

We see it differently. We believe their lending experience, credit knowledge, and relationships are exactly what make this model work. Instead of being limited to one institution’s credit appetite, they can use that expertise to help borrowers navigate an entire market of lenders.

We’re also learning that it’s much easier to explain our value after someone has experienced the problem. A business owner who has just spent three months with the wrong lender immediately understands why matching a transaction to the right bank matters. That’s the paradox of creating a new category. The customers who most readily understand your value are often the ones who have already suffered from the problem you’re trying to prevent.

So how do you change that? There’s a temptation in business to measure every marketing initiative by the leads it produces next week or next quarter. But when you’re trying to change how an entire market thinks, the payoff may be much further down the road. You’re trying to break an old habit, not just generate another inquiry.

I came away from the lending conference realizing that after more than 15 years, we still have a lot of work to do. We have made progress, built relationships, and helped a lot of business owners. But the old perception of what a broker does persists. I’m beginning to think that’s not just a marketing issue. It’s the central strategic challenge of the business we’re building.

Ami Kassar

For more than 20 years, Ami has challenged executives to think differently about how they capitalize growth. Regularly featured in national media including The New York Times, Huffington Post, The Wall Street Journal, Entrepreneur, Forbes and Fox Business News, Ami also writes a weekly column for Inc. Magazine. He has advised the White House, the Federal Reserve Bank and the Treasury Department on credit markets.  

Next
Next

Could My Business Survive 30 Days Without Me?